Movies: Thinking as a Christian #1

It was 1986. The film was Short Circuit

Short Circuit

We sat with friends in the middle of a crowded theater,

about 300 people. 

The story is entertaining. A military robot is struck by lightening, suddenly becoming human. The robot quickly gains knowledge and learns by experience. The child-like nature of the machine is contrasted with silly human responses. Ally Sheedy befriends the unusual creature protecting it from those she deems a threat. Steve Guttenberg, creator of the robot, falls in love with the Ally, she in turn allows her suitor access to the robot-now-human.

In a face-to-face meeting, scientist and science experiment dialogue. Earnestly seeking answers to how metal becomes man, Guttenberg’s character is amazed at his original creation. The military, unable to control their latest weapon, seeks to destroy the machine. robot

“They are coming to kill you,” says the scientist.

“Killing is wrong,” retorts the Robot.

“Who told you killing is wrong?” questions the scientist.

“I told me killing is wrong,” is the ethically charged response.

Without thinking about the 300 other people in the theater, I stood up, pointed at the screen, and said in a voice all could hear, 

Thinking“That is not ethically possible!” 

Robin, my embarrassed wife, is trying desperately to get me back in my seat. All the while I am fishing for paper and pen to write my thoughts. Back in my chair, Robin whispers in my ear,

“Can’t you ever stop thinking?!” 

The answer is the same after 30 years. 

No.

Early in my teaching vocation, I began to train students how to watch movies, how to write movie reviews. Since the early 1990’s, classes were watching full length feature films; interactive responses followed. We engaged Harrison Ford’s scientist who thought he could control creation in Mosquito Coast. We saw through the wrong-headed, romanticized educational views of human nature from Robin Williams’ Dead Poet’s Society. We countered errant truth claims resident during Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade.Mosquito Coast

If you ask my students now what they remember about my classes then, they will smile and say,

“He ruined watching movies for me forever.” 

Now adults, teaching their own children, students are now training their kids to think about what they are watching. 

You can read my philosophy about how Scripture teaches we should “test the spirits.” You can read my essay which explains my biblical view of engaging cinema.  You can read my educational approach here.  But if you really want to know the end result of interpreting movies from a Christian point of view, ask my students.

And I bet you could even find a few people who would tell you,

“Yeah, I remember when this crazed guy stood up in the middle of the auditorium and talked to the screen.” 

I still talk to screens today. 

 

 

Movies: Thinking as a Christian #2

“Why?”  There is no “Why”!!   “What does Yoda’s statement to Skywalker mean?” I asked the class. We had just seen a video clip from the movie The Empire Strikes Back. “Skywalker wants to know a reason for what is happening,” one young voice proclaimed. “Yeah.  ‘Why?’ is a question of purpose,” another astutely observed. I...

Movies: Thinking as a Christian #3

“My parents had a HUGE fight and it’s all your fault.”
jon don

I had given a Christian convictions assignment. 

I had wanted to include the parents in the discussion. 

That turned out to be a mistake.

Students had to address WHY they had accepted certain convictions. They had to substantiate their positions from Scripture. And parental direction is important. 

As it turned out, the discussion between one dad and mom became a heated argument. It seemed they didn’t even agree about what was acceptable in their home. Mom thought strict controls were in order. Dad considered the whole issue to be overblown. What did it matter what kids watched?

Joseph-Gordon-Levitt-06Joseph Gordon-Levitt answered that question this week on an NPR interview.

We like to think, “Ah, it doesn’t matter what I watch, it’s all just harmless entertainment.” And it’s not entirely true. Especially if you watch it repeatedly. I think that the stuff we watch does matter and it does work its way into the way that we see the world. 

Gordon-Levitt’s perspective encompasses all consumed media. NPR‘s title strikes the right cord: “On Life and the Lenses We Look Through.” The actor emphasizes media’s impact on human objectification and its influence on expectations, including commercial advertising.

Naturalistic materialism, antithetic to the biblical view, replaces creation with consumption.

Christian convictions about watching movies should be clear and concise. Here are five of mine.

1. Retell Human Experience  Good and bad, rebellion and righteousness are fully illustrated throughout Scripture (Judges, Kings). Clint Eastwood’s movie A Perfect World reflects God’s perspective: humans are shown for what we are, inherently corrupt.  The good guys aren’t always so good and the bad guys aren’t always so bad.

2. Enjoy the Creation  God’s world is good (1 Tim 4:1-6). Movies like Ridley Scott’s A Good Year remind us what is important in this life.

3. Know Evil Without Participating in Evil  Believers must function in the society in which they find themselves (Lev 18:1-5). Stuck between the darkness of Egyptian mythologies and Canaanite deities, a movie like The Mission certainly gives a good example of what we are up against in this world.

4. Defend Truth, Goodness and Beauty  Declaring God’s work in all arenas of life is the believer’s responsibility (Ps 145:3-13). People Like Us is a film focused on the goodness of family; and family might not be exactly who or what we expect.

5. Critique Worldviews  To expose other systems of thought by Biblical revelation is a necessary component in Christian apologetics (1 John 4:1). M. Night Shyamalan was having a crisis of faith when he wrote Signs. Mel Gibson agreed to play the pastor who had lost his faith. As this scene suggests, everyone has a view of the world.

Joseph Gordon-Levitt is right: what we consume in culture impacts how we think, how we live.

It is important for Christians to know why they watch movies. We might not always agree, but we should have established biblical principles that guide our decisions.

I felt bad about those two parents who had a HUGE fight in front of their son about convictions.

But in many ways it was good.

Folks need to understand how important forming convictions about what we watch will impact how we live.